Search
Low stone-and-stucco home with closed glass doors, a limestone terrace, and sculptural desert planting in a gravel approach.

The 13 Acres at Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway Came With a Hillside Attached

October 22, 2026

"We're trading a piece of property that is going to be commercial, and the undisturbed portion is a loss, but in return we're getting undisturbed land on a mountainside right in the view corridor, so I think that's a good trade," Mayor Robert Morris said in May, according to the Cave Creek/Carefree Independent. "It's the whole purpose of the code."

If you drive the southeast corner of Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway, you've seen the ground change this fall. The project is called Black Mountain Marketplace. Most coverage has been about what the corner will become. The more lasting outcome sits up the slope. The Town allowed this parcel to be cleared completely, and in return it secured a piece of Black Mountain that will stay as it is.

The rule the corner didn't follow

Cave Creek normally requires a development site to leave at least 20% of its land undisturbed. According to the Town's May 19, 2026 staff report, staff approved a site plan for the 13 acres on one condition. Before any building permits could be issued, the Town Council had to approve a Transfer Development Rights agreement, or else the project had to meet that 20% minimum.

The developer took the agreement route. It proposed disturbing the entire property and landscaping 27% of it, which is more than the minimum landscape area. In exchange it would dedicate 98,298 square feet of required undisturbed area on two hillside parcels, 211-13-014B and 211-13-014C, and place that land in a conservation easement under the Town Code. That comes to about two and a quarter acres of mountainside.

The staff report points to the General Plan, which supports commercial development and also calls for limiting development in hillside view corridors within the Town Core. Staff wrote that this proposal "allows for both to occur."

The Independent reported that the council approved the agreement in May. Councilmember Cynthia Driskell made the motion and welcomed the chance to "keep adding little parcels to our open space."

What the corner gets instead of undisturbed desert

Senior Planner Steven Perales told the council that the 27% landscaped area would be "majority of it will be street frontage and installing trails and so on," as quoted in the Independent's report.

So the landscaping will sit mainly along the two roads people drive past every day. The Town's September 23 announcement says the developer prepared a Native Plant Inventory and a Salvage Plan with a licensed professional. Native cacti and trees were salvaged into a nursery for later use on the site. When Town inspectors checked, they found more trees and cacti that could be saved, and those were preserved too.

Some of the desert that used to cover the parcel is waiting nearby to be replanted along the frontage. The two and a quarter acres on Black Mountain are the part of the deal that won't be moved or rebuilt.

The water question, settled at the council table

Councilmember Driskell asked how much water the development might use. Perales answered before the Development Services Director could. "This property is going to be serviced by city of Phoenix water," he said, according to the Independent.

The Town's September announcement put it more broadly. The City of Phoenix will supply water for development south of Carefree Highway, "ensuring Cave Creek's water resources remain unaffected." For a town that pays close attention to its water supply, this means a new shopping center at its southern edge doesn't add demand on Cave Creek's own system.

A corner that was always meant for this

The project is new, but the plan for the site is decades old. The parcel was zoned commercial before Cave Creek incorporated in 1986. The Town says the intersection "has long been envisioned as a vital commercial hub." KTAR repeated that history in its October 4 report and noted that the Town expects the project to strengthen its sales tax base.

The surrounding retail is already in place. The Walmart Supercenter is at 34399 N Cave Creek Rd, Lowe's is at 34700 N Cave Creek Rd, and Sprouts is at 5355 E Carefree Hwy. The 13 acres are one of the last large undeveloped pieces in a shopping area people already use every week. The Town got its hillside in exchange for building on a site that was zoned commercial all along.

What's actually signed, and when

The hillside easement is settled. The retail roster is still being filled in. Here is where things stand as of mid-October 2026:

  • Anchor: Mountainside Fitness. The gym's Cave Creek location page lists 34400 N Cave Creek Rd, labels it "Coming Soon," and offers a pre-opening membership special.
  • Opening: Mountainside's Greater Phoenix "Coming Soon" page says the Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway location is "Coming Summer 2027."
  • Everyone else: In September and October, the Town, the Independent and KTAR all reported that tenants were still negotiating. The Independent said the project "awaits retailers."
  • Layout: The approved site plan has nine commercial lots.

The developer's own marketing material shows what kinds of businesses the pads are designed for. A February 2026 leasing brochure offered pads on ground leases. The permitted uses included drive-through, convenience store and automotive. The brochure projected groundbreaking in the third quarter of 2026. That quarter ended in September. By then the Town was describing the project as "taking shape," with plants salvaged and inspected, and it gave no date for the center as a whole. The same brochure's plan showed a 40,500-square-foot major building and about 7,612 square feet of shop space. These are marketing figures and could change before final construction.

Put together, the corner has one confirmed tenant, a gym, and its opening is about three seasons away. The remaining lots are being leased for uses that fit the busy commercial area around them. Until new names are announced, guesses about specific restaurants or shops are only guesses.

The part of the deal you can already see

The preserved land is on Black Mountain, on the two parcels named in the staff report, in the view corridor the mayor described. The Town's announcement says the acreage was originally zoned residential. It was acquired and set aside as open space "safeguarding Cave Creek's unique landscape and view corridors through a Transfer of Density."

Residents who want the exact location of the parcels or the latest on the site plan can contact the Town of Cave Creek Planning Department, which the Town lists as the contact for the project.

A corner like this changes in stages, and the Cave Creek sellers we work with often want to know how a nearby project could come up in a buyer's questions. If your property is close to Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway and you'd like a clear picture of where your home stands while the corner fills in, Fine Homes Group is glad to help. Request a complimentary home valuation, or schedule a white-glove consultation with Dan Ward and the team.

Follow Us On Instagram